What to Do If Your Business Receives a Litigation Hold Letter

Nov 14, 2026

litigation letter
A litigation hold letter formally notifies your business to preserve all evidence related to a pending or expected lawsuit. If you receive one, stop routine record deletion and contact a business attorney right away.

Most businesses never see a litigation hold letter coming. It might come from a former employee’s attorney, a customer who was injured on your property or a vendor in a contract dispute. The letter does not necessarily mean your business has been sued. But it does change your legal obligations the moment you receive it, and your response in the first few days can shape the case long before anyone steps into a courtroom.

What Is a Litigation Hold Letter?

A litigation hold letter, sometimes called a preservation letter, is a written notice that litigation is pending or reasonably anticipated. It describes the dispute and asks the recipient to preserve evidence that may be relevant to it. The goal is to keep evidence available for discovery. Once your business is on notice, deleting or altering relevant information can lead to court sanctions, even when it happens as part of a normal records policy.

When Does the Duty to Preserve Evidence Begin?

The duty to preserve evidence begins as soon as your business can reasonably expect a lawsuit, which is often before a preservation letter arrives. The letter itself is simply formal notice.

The Tennessee Supreme Court addressed this in Tatham v. Bridgestone Americas Holding, Inc., a spoliation case involving the loss or destruction of evidence that should have been kept. The court said judges should consider whether a party knew, or should have known, the evidence mattered to a lawsuit already underway or likely to be filed. Federal courts follow a similar rule for emails, texts and other electronic records.

In practice, a serious workplace injury, a demand letter, an employment dispute such as a discrimination complaint or a customer threatening to sue can all put your business on notice of an impending lawsuit. Other examples include a serious collision involving a company vehicle, a claim that your product caused injury or a contract dispute involving threatened legal action. The duty can also arise when your business anticipates bringing its own lawsuit. If the circumstances make litigation reasonably foreseeable, start preserving relevant records right away instead of waiting for a letter.If something like that happens, start preserving records right away instead of waiting for a letter.

 

Immediate Steps to Take After Receiving a Litigation Hold Letter

Contact Counsel the Same Day

Call your attorney before anyone opens, moves, forwards or “cleans up” files connected to the dispute. Well-meaning employees can alter evidence just by reorganizing folders or deleting what look like duplicates.

Suspend Routine Deletion

Identify and pause any process that could erase relevant material, including email retention settings, auto-delete features on messaging apps, security cameras that record over old footage, scheduled document shredding and the practice of wiping or reissuing laptops and phones when employees leave.

Identify Custodians and Data Sources

Custodians are the people most likely to have relevant information, such as managers and employees directly involved in the dispute. Then map where their information lives, which typically includes company email, cell phones and text messages, shared drives, cloud storage, accounting or customer management software, security footage and physical files.

Issue an Internal Hold Memo

Send a written hold notice to every custodian explaining what they must keep and that normal deletion no longer applies to it. Keep the language plain, ask each recipient to confirm in writing that they received and understood it and send periodic reminders while the matter is open.

Document What You Do

Record when the letter arrived, who received the hold memo and which systems were paused. That record helps show your business took reasonable steps if preservation is ever questioned.

What Counts as Evidence Under a Litigation Hold?

A litigation hold generally covers information related to the dispute in any format, including:

  •         Emails and attachments
  •         Text messages, including messages on personal phones used for work
  •         Slack, Microsoft Teams and other workplace chat platforms
  •         Metadata, which records details such as when a file was created, edited or sent
  •         Backups and archives, including older backup tapes
  •         Surveillance and security video
  •         Social media posts and business accounts
  •         Paper files, handwritten notes and calendars
  •         Physical items such as equipment, products or vehicles

Because copying, forwarding or even opening files can change metadata, counsel should guide the collection process.

What Happens If Evidence Is Lost or Destroyed?

Destroying, altering or failing to preserve relevant evidence is known as spoliation. Under Tennessee Rule of Civil Procedure 34A.02, courts may impose sanctions on a party or its agent who discards, destroys, mutilates, alters or conceals evidence. In federal court, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e) addresses the loss of electronically stored information that should have been preserved for anticipated or pending litigation, allowing corrective measures or sanctions when the rule’s requirements are met.

Before 2015, Tennessee courts generally required proof of intentional destruction before imposing certain sanctions, such as a negative inference. In Tatham, the Tennessee Supreme Court held that intentional misconduct is not a prerequisite for spoliation sanctions and instructed trial courts to look at the totality of the circumstances. 

Relevant factors include the culpability of the party that lost the evidence, the prejudice to the other side, whether the party knew or should have known the evidence was relevant, and the least severe sanction that would remedy the harm.

Depending on the circumstances, sanctions can include:

  •         An instruction allowing the jury to infer that the missing evidence would have hurt your business.
  •         Barring your business from introducing certain evidence or supporting certain claims or defenses.
  •         Treating disputed facts as established against you.
  •         Ordering your business to pay the other side’s attorney’s fees.
  •         Dismissal of your claims or a default judgment in the most serious cases.

Federal and multistate litigation brings a separate standard for lost electronic information. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e) lets courts order measures to cure prejudice when a party fails to take reasonable steps to preserve electronic information. The harshest sanctions, including an adverse inference, dismissal or default judgment, require a finding that the party intended to deprive the other side of the information.

That gap matters for Tennessee businesses. In state court, an honest mistake can still lead to serious consequences.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does receiving a litigation hold letter mean my business is being sued?

Not necessarily. Many letters are sent before a lawsuit is filed, often while the other party is evaluating a claim. The duty to preserve applies either way.

Do employees’ personal phones fall under a litigation hold?

They can. If employees use personal phones to text or email about work matters connected to the dispute, those messages may need to be preserved.

How long does a litigation hold last?

A hold typically stays in place until the matter is fully resolved, including any appeals, and your attorney confirms that it can be lifted.

Should my business respond to the letter?

Often, yes. Your attorney can acknowledge the letter, clarify its scope and push back on overly broad demands.

Why Legal Guidance Matters

Because failing to preserve evidence can have serious consequences, it is best to consult an attorney when your business receives a preservation demand.A preservation demand is not something to manage in-house alone. Your first steps can determine whether key evidence survives and whether sanctions follow later.

If your business has received a litigation hold letter, the corporate law and commercial litigation attorneys at Hudson, Reed & Christiansen can help you respond, build a defensible preservation plan and protect your position from the start. Contact our office the same day the letter arrives and before anyone touches the related files.

 

Do You Need Legal Help?